Bulldog and Rhodesian Tobacco Pipes

What is the difference between a "Bulldog" and "Rhodesian" shape?

Pipe shape classifications are not absolute. Many pipe makers and pipe companies simply use their own naming conventions and have unique standards for classifying pipes. Also, in different parts of the world, pipe shapes sometimes are referred to a bit differently than they are in the USA.

But there actually is some debate about the distinction between a "Bulldog" and a "Rhodesian" shape.

Almost everyone agrees that the quintessential, classic bulldog shape has a straight diamond shank, a tapered diamond stem, and the bowl is tilted forward a few degrees. The bowl shape is like two cones joined together at the base with the "point" of the top cone cut off. Most classic bulldogs also have one or two grooves carved into the bowl where the two cone shapes come together (although some bulldogs do not have these grooves).

Classic Bulldog Shape (Diamond, Straight Shank)

Image Source: www.smokershaven.com

Classic Rhodesian Shape (Round, Bent Shank)

Image Source: www.puff.com

Bulldog or Rhodesian? (Diamond, Bent Shank)

Image source: www.smokingpipes.com

The controversy begins when the shank/stem are bent (instead of straight) or rounded (instead of diamond-shaped). Some feel that any bulldog-shaped bowl with a bent shank/stem is automatically a Rhodesian. Others, like me, distinguish between the shapes based upon the shape of the shank, whether or not the pipe is bent or straight. While this notion does not rise to the level of a "law," I believe it is the most common way of distinguishing the two shapes.

In the end, each pipe maker, collector, and enthusiast will make his own determination. But for me, a bulldog always has a diamond shank and a Rhodesian always has a rounded shank, regardless of straight or bent shank.

Pipe Shapes and Styles: Looks or Quality?

Do the different pipe shapes/styles affect the smoking quality or are they purely aesthetic?

The different pipe shapes can have either an aesthetic or functional purpose (or both). Part of the fun of collecting pipes is to have a variety of different shapes, sizes, and finishes. But each pipe does have unique smoking qualities. Some shapes are more comfortable to hold in the hand or mouth. Others can hold larger or smaller amounts of tobacco. Depending on the craftsmanship, different shapes can also have an impact on the airflow and other combustion related issues.

Image source: s113077598.onlinehome.us

Generally speaking, the smoking quality of a given pipe has less to do with the shape and more to do with the overall quality of craftsmanship or our own habits and tendencies while smoking different pipes. I believe any differences in smoking quality is only indirectly related to the geometric shape of the pipe or bowl itself. This is because the performance of a pipe is actually tied to a combination of factors.

For example, briar quality and preparation--long before it is made into a particular pipe shape by the craftsman--can dramatically affect the smokability of a pipe. Other factors, such as the type of tobacco, how the pipe is filled, pace and method of smoking, and even weather conditions can affect how well a pipe performs.

However, when it comes to pipe shapes directly affecting smokability, the following observations could be noted. Keep in mind these are very general comments and are not necessarily true in every case.

Image source: serjacopo.com

• Pipe shapes with thick-walled bowls tend to smoke cooler because the briar is able to absorb more moisture and heat.
• Pipe shapes that employ long shanks or long stems tend to provide cooler, drier, more comfortable smokes since the smoke has more time to cool before it reaches the mouth and tongue.
• Pipes with rusticated or sandblasted finished often feel cooler to the hand during a smoke because of the way these uneven finishes dissipate heat.
• Straight pipes tend to have an easier draw due to the fact that the airway is undiverted and more direct from stem, through shank, to bowl. The easier draw can allow a more gentle, smooth smoke.
• Full or 3/4 bent pipes are more comfortable when hanging from the jaw than straight or lesser bent pipes because of the way weight is distributed.
• Pipes with tall or large diameter bowls provide much longer smokes due to the simple fact that the tobacco chamber can hold more tobacco.
• Conical bowl shapes can sometimes be more easily "clogged" by bits of tobacco, thus causing difficulties with draw and air flow.

Motorcycle and Aviator pipe: Wind Resistant!

Image source: monstermarketplace.com

There are additional generalizations like these that could be made. But based upon my own experience and research, I do not believe there are any substantial differences in smokability that are caused by the shape of the pipe or bowl. Nearly any pipe of any shape, if it is well-made and smoked properly, should yield an enjoyable smoking experience.

And that is one of the great beauties of pipe smoking. There really is no such thing as a "right" or "wrong" shape or a "better" or "worse" shape. It only matters that you personally like the shape and enjoy smoking it.